loader image
Home » Blog » Genetics are a factor – Why semaglutide and similar drugs don’t work equally well for everyone

Gene­tics are a factor – Why semaglutide and similar drugs don’t work equally well for everyone

GLP‑1 receptor agonists are among the success stories of modern diabetes care. They lower HbA1c, support weight loss, and—depending on the specific drug and the patient’s risk profile—offer addi­tional cardio­me­ta­bolic bene­fits. Nevert­heless, a fami­liar pheno­menon persists in prac­tice: Some pati­ents respond less well than expected, even though the admi­nis­tra­tion, dose, and dura­tion of therapy are correct.

A recent study in Genome Medi­cine provides a possible genetic expl­ana­tion for this. The focus is on the PAM gene, which encodes peptidyl-glycine alpha-amida­ting monooxygenase.

This enzyme is involved in the amida­tion of nume­rous bioac­tive peptides—including GLP‑1. Two hypo­mor­phic PAM vari­ants studied, p.S539W and p.D563G, are asso­ciated with an increased risk of type 2 diabetes; combined, they are carried by about one in ten people.

More GLP‑1 does not mean increased effectiveness

In the study, PAM acti­vity was signi­fi­cantly reduced in carriers of these vari­ants: by about 52% for p.S539W and by about 20% for p.D563G.

Inte­res­t­ingly, carriers also had elevated circu­la­ting GLP‑1 levels. While this may initi­ally sound like an advan­tage, it does not trans­late into a stronger effect. Reduced endo­ge­nous GLP‑1 sensi­ti­vity was parti­cu­larly evident with p.S539W—consistent with the concept of GLP‑1 resistance.

The mouse data also fit this picture: Pam knockout mice exhi­bited acce­le­rated gastric emptying, responded less well to exendin‑4, and showed atte­nu­ated signal trans­duc­tion via the GLP‑1 receptor in the pylorus.

So what does this mean for treatment?

Clini­cally, the effect was measurable: In a meta-analysis of three cohorts with 1,119 parti­ci­pants, the reduc­tion in HbA1c under GLP-1RA therapy was lower in p.S539W carriers than in non-carriers. This diffe­rence was not observed for metformin, sulfo­nylu­reas, and DPP‑4 inhibitors.

This does not yet change any guide­lines. But PAM could help iden­tify GLP-1RA non-respon­ders earlier —and make treat­ment decis­ions less based on the prin­ciple of “let’s see if it works.”

Umapa­thy­sivam MM et al. Type 2 diabetes risk alleles in peptidyl-glycine alpha-amida­ting monooxy­ge­nase influence GLP‑1 levels and response to GLP‑1 receptor agonists. Genome Medi­cine (2026).